Trending
Judge Asks Dog To Settle Case By Revealing Its True Owner
Judge Judy decided that no amount of paperwork was going to tell her who the stolen dog truly belonged to— so she let the dog make the decision himself in the middle of court.
Jessica
05.23.19

Dogs know their people and those bonds can never be broken.

That’s why Judge Judy decided to take a unique approach to ruling on a case involving a stolen dog named Baby Boy.

The defendant wasn’t actually the person who stole the dog, but rather they purchased the pup off of someone else for $50. But when the true owner found out what happened and the buyers refused to relinquish their new pet, he took them to court. Judge Judy’s court.

Screencap via YouTube
Source:
Screencap via YouTube

Despite the new owner insisting that the dog they purchased is rightfully theirs, Judge Judy decided to hand over the verdict to the Baby Boy himself.

And the little white poodle mix pup made the ruling an easy one.

In a clip that’s now been viewed almost 4 million times, Judge Judy orders the defendant to go and get the dog. She looks unsure, but doesn’t have much of a choice.

Screencap via YouTube
Source:
Screencap via YouTube

While a family member goes to fetch Baby Boy, the buyer tries to ply the judge with documents from the vet explaining the age of the dog. She argues that the dog can’t belong to the plaintiff because a vet told her that the dog is a different age than the man says. But Judge Judy quickly points out that nothing a vet can say can prove who a dog truly belongs to.

Screencap via YouTube
Source:
Screencap via YouTube

In this case, possession is not in the defendant’s favor and it’s clear that whoever the dog runs to once it’s put down in the courtroom is going to be deemed the rightful owner.

As the woman brings the little dog in, he looks calm enough in her arms. Then Judge Judy says: “Madame, listen to me carefully: Put the dog down! Put the dog down.”

Screencap via YouTube
Source:
Screencap via YouTube

It’s clear the defendants are reluctant to do so since they know what’s going to happen. While they are still convinced that buying the dog makes it theirs, they know the dog once belonged to the plaintiff and Baby Boy’s reaction is going to be all the judge needs to make a ruling.

And once he’s put down and gets a whiff of his original owner, Baby Boy bounds happily over to his rightful family, jumping all him.

Screencap via YouTube
Source:
Screencap via YouTube

It’s an emotional moment as the two are reunited and there are plenty of tears.

But the defendant doesn’t give up immediately and instead futilely insists the dog does that to everyone.

But Judge Judy is not buying it and neither is the courtroom which erupts in applause as the dog bolts to his owner.

Screencap via YouTube
Source:
Screencap via YouTube

The defendants look on annoyed, but it’s too late.

The dog is ecstatic as his master greets him with “oh good boy” and returns his kisses.

Screencap via YouTube
Source:
Screencap via YouTube

At this point, the judge has had enough. She tells the real owner to take his dog home and dismisses the courtroom.

“This means everything in the world to me,” the man says tearfully in the post-hearing interview. “This is like my child.”

While the episode originally aired in 2012, the clip has recently resurfaced online and is once again delighting dog-lovers who love to see a good reunion.

Be sure to scroll down below to see the video of the heartwarming reunion.

Please SHARE this with your friends and family.

Article Sources:
To learn more read our Editorial Standards.
Advertisement